test(13): add phase verification report

2026-05-16 18:18:26 +02:00 · 2026-05-16 18:18:26 +02:00 · be84d1f803
commit be84d1f803
parent 9dcf628322
1 changed files with 180 additions and 0 deletions
--- a/.planning/phases/13-design-system-foundation/13-VERIFICATION.md
+++ b/.planning/phases/13-design-system-foundation/13-VERIFICATION.md
@ -0,0 +1,180 @@
+---
+phase: 13-design-system-foundation
+verified: 2026-05-16T12:30:00Z
+status: human_needed
+score: 9/9 must-haves verified
+overrides_applied: 0
+human_verification:
+  - test: "Visual sign-off on catalog — run `cd backend && just catalog` and visit http://localhost:8080/ui-catalog"
+    expected: "11 component sections visible in sidebar (alphabetical), each section renders component variants with templ call snippets below; tokens look correct (brand purple #804eec on primary buttons, pill badges, rounded cards)"
+    why_human: "Plan 05 Task 2 is a checkpoint:human-verify gate. It was auto-approved in auto mode. Visual correctness of token values, component shapes, and layout cannot be verified programmatically."
+  - test: "Verify catalog DS-label numbering is acceptable"
+    expected: "Section headings label Empty State as DS-07, Table as DS-08, Icon Button as DS-09, Form Field / Select / Textarea labels are understood as informational only"
+    why_human: "The catalog uses mismatched DS numbers vs REQUIREMENTS.md (Empty State shows DS-09 instead of DS-07; Icon Button shows DS-07 instead of DS-09; Select shows DS-10 and Table shows DS-11 which do not exist). The underlying components are correctly implemented. A human should decide whether catalog heading labels need correction."
+---
+
+# Phase 13: Design System Foundation Verification Report
+
+**Phase Goal:** Establish a shared Go+HTMX design system — token vocabulary, component library, and visual catalog — so all subsequent phases ship consistent, on-brand UI without per-feature style decisions.
+**Verified:** 2026-05-16T12:30:00Z
+**Status:** human_needed
+**Re-verification:** No — initial verification
+
+## Goal Achievement
+
+### Observable Truths
+
+| #  | Truth | Status | Evidence |
+|----|-------|--------|----------|
+| 1  | `base.css` defines full CSS custom property vocabulary matching go-backend | VERIFIED | 223 lines, `color-brand-primary` appears 4 times; `grep -c 'color-brand-primary' base.css` returns 4 |
+| 2  | All 10 component types exist as templ components (button, input, textarea, select, card, badge, modal, empty-state, table, icon-button) | VERIFIED | All templ files present: button.templ, input.templ, textarea.templ, select.templ, card.templ, badge.templ, modal.templ, empty_state.templ, table.templ, icon_button.templ |
+| 3  | `tailwind.input.css` imports all component CSS files | VERIFIED | 14 total `@import` lines for `web/ui` files; base + auth + 12 components; no app.css (intentional per D-A02) |
+| 4  | Component catalog route exists and is build-tag-gated | VERIFIED | `catalog_route_catalog.go` has `//go:build catalog`; `catalog_route_stub.go` has `//go:build !catalog`; `RegisterCatalogRoute(r)` in router.go; `go build ./...` and `go build -tags catalog ./...` both pass |
+| 5  | All existing templates compile and tests pass with no regressions | VERIFIED | `go test ./... -count=1` — all packages pass: auth, db, files, jobs, web, web/ui, templates |
+| 6  | ButtonClass() emits multi-class output; no compound button strings in templates | VERIFIED | `ButtonClass()` returns `"ui-button ui-button-solid ui-button-default ui-button-md"`; grep for compound strings in backend/templates/ returns 0 matches |
+| 7  | Card uses typed Header/Body/Footer Props API | VERIFIED | `card.templ` contains `type CardProps struct` with nil-guard conditionals (`if props.Header != nil`) |
+| 8  | Select component has inline JS for open/close and HTMX re-init | VERIFIED | `__uiSelectInitAll` and `htmx:afterSwap` listener present in select.templ |
+| 9  | FormField conditionally renders error, hint, and label regions | VERIFIED | `if props.Error != ""` guard at line 22 of form_field.templ; TestFormField_NoErrorWhenEmpty passes |
+
+**Score:** 9/9 truths verified
+
+### Deferred Items
+
+None.
+
+### Required Artifacts
+
+| Artifact | Expected | Status | Details |
+|----------|----------|--------|---------|
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/base.css` | Full 223-line token vocabulary | VERIFIED | 223 lines, `--color-brand-primary: #804eec` present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/auth.css` | Auth provider button CSS | VERIFIED | 5 `.auth-provider-*` selector matches |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/variants.go` | All variant enums including Ghost, Primary, IconButton, SpacingStep | VERIFIED | ButtonVariantGhost, BadgeVariantPrimary, IconButtonVariant, IconButtonTone, SpacingStep all declared |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/helpers.go` | buttonType, inputType, inputID, textareaRows helpers | VERIFIED | All 4 functions present, `strconv` imported |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/button.css` | Multi-class selectors + ghost variant | VERIFIED | `.ui-button-solid.ui-button-default {` and `.ui-button-ghost {` present; no auth-provider CSS |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/badge.css` | Pill shape + primary variant | VERIFIED | `border-radius: 999px` and `.ui-badge-primary {` present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/card.css` | Token-based card with header/body/footer | VERIFIED | `.ui-card-header,` present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/card.templ` | Typed Header/Body/Footer Props API | VERIFIED | `type CardProps struct`, nil-guard for Header |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/input.css` | `.ui-input` with min-height 44px | VERIFIED | `.ui-input {` and `min-height: 44px` present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/input.templ` | InputProps with inputType/inputID helpers | VERIFIED | `type InputProps struct` with Name, ID, Type, Disabled, Required fields |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/textarea.css` | `.ui-textarea` with min-height 7rem, resize vertical | VERIFIED | All three properties present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/textarea.templ` | TextareaProps with textareaRows default | VERIFIED | `type TextareaProps struct`, Rows field |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/select.css` | `.ui-select-control` with min-height 44px | VERIFIED | `.ui-select-control {` present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/select.templ` | SelectProps + inline JS | VERIFIED | `type SelectProps struct`, `__uiSelectInitAll` in script block |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/select_helpers.go` | selectPlaceholder, selectOptionSelected and others | VERIFIED | Both functions present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/form-field.css` | `.ui-form-field`, `.ui-form-error` | VERIFIED | Both selectors present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/form_field.templ` | FormFieldProps with conditional error/hint | VERIFIED | `type FormFieldProps struct`, `if props.Error != ""` guard |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/modal.css` | `.ui-modal-backdrop`, `.ui-modal-panel` | VERIFIED | Both selectors present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/modal.templ` | ModalProps with Title/Body/Actions | VERIFIED | `type ModalProps struct` present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/empty-state.css` | `.ui-empty-state`, dashed border | VERIFIED | `.ui-empty-state {` present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/empty_state.templ` | EmptyStateProps with Icon as templ.Component | VERIFIED | `type EmptyStateProps struct` present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/table.css` | `.ui-table-shell` | VERIFIED | `.ui-table-shell {` present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/table.templ` | TableProps with Head/Body | VERIFIED | `ui-table-shell` in template |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/icon-button.css` | `.ui-icon-button`, `.borderless-icon-button` | VERIFIED | Both present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/icon_button.templ` | IconButton + UIIcon templ function | VERIFIED | `templ UIIcon(kind string)` with 8 icon cases + fallback |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/spacing.css` | `.ui-space-x-md` and other steps | VERIFIED | `.ui-space-x-md {` present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/space.templ` | SpaceX/SpaceY with SpacingStep | VERIFIED | SpaceProps struct, SpaceXClass/SpaceYClass used |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/catalog/catalog.templ` | Single-page catalog layout with 11 sections | VERIFIED | "Component Catalog" title, 11 section anchors present |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/catalog/examples.go` | Typed Example structs per component | VERIFIED | buttonExamples(), modalExamples(), badgeExamples() and others present |
+| `backend/internal/web/catalog_route_catalog.go` | Build-tagged catalog route | VERIFIED | Starts with `//go:build catalog` |
+| `backend/internal/web/catalog_route_stub.go` | No-op stub for production builds | VERIFIED | Starts with `//go:build !catalog` |
+| `backend/tailwind.input.css` | 14 total CSS imports including spacing.css | VERIFIED | 14 imports confirmed by grep |
+
+### Key Link Verification
+
+| From | To | Via | Status | Details |
+|------|----|-----|--------|---------|
+| `backend/tailwind.input.css` | `auth.css` | `@import` | WIRED | `@import "./internal/web/ui/auth.css";` present |
+| `backend/tailwind.input.css` | `spacing.css` (and all 12 components) | `@import` | WIRED | 14 total imports confirmed |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/variants.go` | `ButtonVariantGhost` | const block | WIRED | `ButtonVariantGhost ButtonVariant = "ghost"` |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/select.templ` | `select_helpers.go` | `selectPlaceholder` calls | WIRED | `selectPlaceholder` called in select.templ |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/textarea.templ` | `helpers.go` | `textareaRows`, `inputID` | WIRED | Both helpers called in textarea.templ |
+| `backend/internal/web/ui/button.templ` | `icon_button.templ` | `@UIIcon(props.Icon)` | WIRED | `@UIIcon(props.Icon)` present in button.templ |
+| `backend/internal/web/router.go` | `RegisterCatalogRoute` | unconditional call | WIRED | `RegisterCatalogRoute(r)` in NewRouter |
+| `backend/internal/web/catalog_route_catalog.go` | `catalog.templ` | templ.Handler render | WIRED | catalogPageHandler() renders catalog package |
+
+### Data-Flow Trace (Level 4)
+
+Not applicable — all Phase 13 artifacts are presentational design system components. No dynamic data sources or database queries are involved. Components receive typed props (compile-time constants or caller-provided values) and render HTML. No data-flow stubs exist.
+
+### Behavioral Spot-Checks
+
+| Behavior | Command | Result | Status |
+|----------|---------|--------|--------|
+| UI test suite passes | `cd backend && go test ./internal/web/ui/... -count=1` | ok (36 tests) | PASS |
+| Full test suite passes | `cd backend && go test ./... -count=1` | ok all packages | PASS |
+| Build without catalog tag | `cd backend && go build ./...` | exit 0, no output | PASS |
+| Build with catalog tag | `cd backend && go build -tags catalog ./...` | exit 0, no output | PASS |
+| ButtonClass multi-class format | grep shows `"ui-button ui-button-solid ui-button-default ui-button-md"` output path | Confirmed in function body | PASS |
+| No compound button strings in templates | `grep -r 'ui-button-soft-neutral-md\|ui-button-solid-default-md' backend/templates/` | 0 matches | PASS |
+| tailwind.input.css import count | `grep -c '@import.*web/ui' backend/tailwind.input.css` | 14 | PASS |
+
+### Probe Execution
+
+No probes defined for Phase 13. Build and test verification performed directly in behavioral spot-checks above.
+
+### Requirements Coverage
+
+| Requirement | Source Plan | Description | Status | Evidence |
+|-------------|------------|-------------|--------|----------|
+| DS-01 | 13-01 | CSS design tokens in base.css matching go-backend vocabulary | SATISFIED | 223-line base.css with `--color-brand-primary: #804eec` and full token set |
+| DS-02 | 13-02 | Button component with primary, secondary, ghost, danger variants | SATISFIED | button.templ/button.css with multi-class selectors, ghost variant, ButtonClass() multi-class output |
+| DS-03 | 13-03 | Input, Textarea, Select form field components | SATISFIED | input.templ, textarea.templ, select.templ all exist with typed Props and CSS |
+| DS-04 | 13-02 | Card component used across views | SATISFIED | card.templ with typed CardProps; auth_login.templ, tablos.templ migrated to typed API |
+| DS-05 | 13-02 | Badge component with semantic tones | SATISFIED | badge.templ with BadgeVariantPrimary; badge.css with pill shape and all tone classes |
+| DS-06 | 13-04 | Modal component for create/edit dialogs | SATISFIED | modal.templ with ModalProps (Title/Body/Actions); modal.css with backdrop + panel |
+| DS-07 | 13-04 | Empty-state component for zero-data views | SATISFIED | empty_state.templ with EmptyStateProps (Icon as templ.Component); empty-state.css |
+| DS-08 | 13-04 | Table component for list views | SATISFIED | table.templ with TableProps (Head/Body); table.css with ui-table-shell |
+| DS-09 | 13-04 | Icon-button component | SATISFIED | icon_button.templ with IconButton + UIIcon (8 icons + fallback); icon-button.css |
+
+All 9 DS requirements claimed by Phase 13 plans are satisfied. No orphaned DS requirements found.
+
+### Anti-Patterns Found
+
+| File | Line | Pattern | Severity | Impact |
+|------|------|---------|----------|--------|
+| `catalog.templ` (DS labels) | Lines 56-66 | Catalog section headings use mismatched DS numbers: Empty State labeled DS-09 (should be DS-07), Icon Button labeled DS-07 (should be DS-09), Select labeled DS-10 (nonexistent), Table labeled DS-11 (nonexistent) | Info | Cosmetic only — labels are documentation strings in a dev-only catalog, not functional requirements. Underlying components are correctly implemented. No user-facing or test-affecting impact. |
+
+No debt markers (`TBD`, `FIXME`, `XXX`) found in any phase 13 modified files.
+
+### Human Verification Required
+
+#### 1. Visual Catalog Sign-Off
+
+**Test:** Run `cd backend && just catalog`, then visit http://localhost:8080/ui-catalog
+**Expected:** 11 component sections visible in sidebar navigation (alphabetical order: badge, button, card, empty-state, form-field, icon-button, input, modal, select, table, textarea). Each section renders all declared component variants with templ call snippets below. Specific checks:
+- Button ghost variant: transparent background, brand-purple text (no colored fill)
+- Badge primary variant: purple-tinted background (different from info blue)
+- Card: header and body regions render as separate sections
+- Modal: panel visible without full-page backdrop overlay
+- EmptyState: icon circle + title + description layout correct
+- Select: dropdown control with chevron indicator
+- IconButton: ghost has no background, solid has filled background
+- Brand purple (#804eec) visible on primary buttons and ghost button text
+- Browser console: no JavaScript errors
+
+**Why human:** Task 2 of Plan 05 is a `checkpoint:human-verify` gate that was auto-approved in auto mode (autonomous execution). Visual correctness of token values (color accuracy, spacing, border-radius, shadow), component shapes, and layout cannot be verified programmatically. This is the explicit gate before Phase 14 begins.
+
+#### 2. Catalog DS-Label Accuracy Decision
+
+**Test:** In the catalog page, check section headings for DS requirement numbers
+**Expected:** Section headings should accurately map DS numbers per REQUIREMENTS.md:
+- Modal = DS-06 (correct in catalog)
+- Empty State = DS-07 (catalog shows DS-09 — WRONG)
+- Table = DS-08 (catalog shows DS-11 — WRONG)
+- Icon Button = DS-09 (catalog shows DS-07 — WRONG)
+- Form Field, Select, Textarea have no matching DS requirement IDs (catalog shows DS-08, DS-10, DS-03b)
+
+**Why human:** Decide whether the catalog label mismatches warrant a correction commit before Phase 14, or if labels are accepted as-is given the catalog is a dev-only tool and the components themselves are all correctly implemented and tested.
+
+### Gaps Summary
+
+No technical gaps found. All 9 DS requirements are implemented, all artifacts exist and are substantive and wired, all tests pass (36 ui tests + full suite), both build variants succeed.
+
+The only open items are:
+1. Human visual sign-off on the catalog (required because Plan 05 Task 2 is a human checkpoint that was auto-approved)
+2. A decision on whether catalog DS-label numbering mismatches need correction (cosmetic, informational)
+
+---
+
+_Verified: 2026-05-16T12:30:00Z_
+_Verifier: Claude (gsd-verifier)_